NAS Codex › Synology › Synology drive status Warning, Critical, Failing or Access Error: what each means

Synology drive status Warning, Critical, Failing or Access Error: what each means

Storage Manager shows a drive in Warning, Critical, Failing or Access Error status. Synology's summary is short: a drive in any of these abnormal statuses "is likely defective and needs replacement." The four are not equally urgent, though. Here is Synology's definition of each, how to look at the drive, and the order to act in.

Written against: Synology Knowledge Center article with Environment DSM 6.2 to 7.1.1 (tagged DSM 7 series and legacy versions) and DSM 7 help (Repair a Storage Pool). Last Updated: November 2026. Vendor menus and wording change between versions; if yours differ, follow the vendor page linked under Sources.

Before anything else: if the data on this NAS is not backed up somewhere else, copy it off first. Do not continue with any step on this page until you have.

Fast Answer

Warning: issues or rising bad sectors detected; keep monitoring. Critical and Failing: Synology says consider replacing the drive and repairing the storage pool. Access Error: communication or read-write failures, possibly with the drive disconnecting; same advice. In every case, back up first, then replace one drive at a time.

Inspect the drive

  1. Go to Storage Manager > HDD/SSD.
  2. Select the drive from the list.
  3. Click the drop-down icon to expand its information, or click Health Info > Overview to see its statistics.

Health statuses, per Synology

StatusSynology's definition
HealthyThe drive is in good condition, or the drive warning has been suppressed or disabled.
WarningThe system has detected issues or an increase in bad sectors on the drive. Even if the drive appears to be working fine, continue to monitor its health and bad sector count.
CriticalThe system has detected one or more critical issues on the drive. To ensure continued reliability, consider replacing the drive and repairing the storage pool.
FailingThe system has detected severe issues on the drive. Drive integrity may not be guaranteed. Consider replacing the drive and repairing the storage pool.
Access ErrorThe system has detected severe issues on the drive. Drive communication errors may have caused it to disconnect, or have resulted in severe read-write failure. Consider replacing the drive and repairing the storage pool.

Note that Healthy can also mean a warning was suppressed or disabled. If you or someone else turned drive warnings off, Healthy is not proof the drive is fine.

What to do, in order

Warning

Watch the bad sector trend: see bad sector count increased. Synology suggests replacing a drive with a rapidly rising count if it enters Critical status.

Critical, Failing or Access Error

  1. Back up anything not already backed up.
  2. Confirm the exact drive on the HDD/SSD page.
  3. Replace it with a healthy drive. Synology's repair help says the replacement must be at least as large as the smallest drive in a RAID 1, 5, 6, 10 or F1 pool (SHR has its own size rules), and that any data on the replacement is erased.
  4. Repair the storage pool: see storage pool degraded for Synology's steps.

The allocation status is a separate column

Next to health, Storage Manager shows an allocation status. Two of Synology's definitions matter here:

For Synology's own advice on a specific drive, expand the drive information and hover over the info icon next to Allocation status.

When to stop and get help

Stop and back up before touching any drive if more than one drive in the same pool is Critical, Failing or Access Error, or if the pool itself shows Crashed. Synology's help says that once a pool is Crashed you can no longer repair it yourself.

Questions

Does a Synology Warning status mean the drive is failing?

Not necessarily. Synology defines Warning as issues or an increase in bad sectors detected, and says to keep monitoring the drive's health and bad sector count even if it seems to work fine.

What is Access Error on a Synology drive?

Synology says severe issues were detected: drive communication errors may have disconnected the drive or caused severe read-write failure. It recommends considering replacing the drive and repairing the storage pool.

Can Healthy be wrong?

Synology's definition of Healthy includes a drive whose warning has been suppressed or disabled, so check whether warnings were turned off.

Sources

Every fact on this page comes from the vendor documents below, opened on 2026-11-14.