NAS Codex › QNAP › QNAP RAID rebuild won't start after replacing a drive in a degraded pool
QNAP RAID rebuild won't start after replacing a drive in a degraded pool
A RAID group was degraded, you put in a replacement drive, and nothing happened: no Warning (Rebuilding), no progress. QNAP says a rebuild usually starts automatically in that situation. When it does not, QNAP's fix is to assign the new drive to the RAID group as a spare disk by hand.
Written against: QTS and QuTS hero (QNAP FAQ last modified 2026-08-11; QTS 5.1.x documentation). Last Updated: November 2026. Vendor menus and wording change between versions; if yours differ, follow the vendor page linked under Sources.
Before anything else: if the data on this NAS is not backed up somewhere else, copy it off first. Do not continue with any step on this page until you have.
Fast Answer
Check that the new drive is at least as large as each current member drive and shows healthy. Then go to Storage & Snapshots > Storage > Storage/Snapshots, select the storage pool or static volume, click Manage, and in the degraded RAID group section click Manage > Configure Spare Disk. Select the replacement drive and click Apply. QNAP says rebuilding then starts immediately. This only applies while the RAID group is degraded, not inactive or offline.
When this page applies
QNAP's FAQ is explicit: "This article only applies to RAID in degraded mode (the number of failed drives is still within RAID fault tolerance)." And: "If the RAID is inactive or offline, use the inactive RAID recovery procedure instead."
So check the pool status first under Storage & Snapshots > Storage > Storage/Snapshots. Warning (Degraded) is the case this page covers. QNAP defines it as one or more RAID groups having the status Degraded, with not enough spare disks available to rebuild them all, which is exactly the situation of a new drive that has not been assigned. Warning (Read-Only) means a RAID group is Not Active: go to the read-only page instead.
Step 1: Check the replacement drive
QNAP's prerequisites:
- "Ensure the replacement drive capacity is equal to or larger than each current RAID member drive."
- If the drive was not bought from a reputable or authorized channel, QNAP warns that its quality may be unreliable. Verify the drive can operate normally before use.
In Storage & Snapshots > Storage > Disks/VJBOD > Disks, the new drive should show health Good. QNAP's disk table lists its "Used Type" as Free when it "has not been assigned any purpose", which is what an unassigned replacement looks like. If it shows Inactive, the NAS cannot detect it: see disk status inactive.
Step 2: Assign it as a spare disk
QNAP's hot spare documentation warns: "All data on the selected disks will be deleted." Select only the new replacement drive. Double-check the bay number and serial number before clicking Apply.
QNAP's steps from the FAQ:
- Log in to the NAS through a web browser.
- Open Storage & Snapshots.
- Go to Storage > Storage/Snapshots.
- Select the target Storage Pool or Static Volume, and click Manage.
- In the degraded RAID group section, click Manage > Configure Spare Disk.
- Select the replacement drive, then click Apply.
QNAP's expected result: "RAID rebuilding starts immediately." When it finishes, the RAID status returns to normal. QNAP's hot spare documentation explains the mechanism: when a disk in the RAID group fails, the hot spare automatically replaces it and QTS copies the data to it, a process called RAID rebuilding.
QNAP's QTS 5.1 documentation also describes a direct route for a Degraded group: select the RAID group under Manage, click Manage and select Rebuild RAID Group, click Rebuild, select the disk or disks and click Apply.
If the drive cannot be selected as a spare
QNAP's troubleshooting list:
- Confirm the drive capacity meets the requirement (equal to or larger than the RAID member drives).
- Confirm the drive health is normal: no S.M.A.R.T. warning and no bad blocks.
- Confirm interface and model compatibility with the NAS.
If none of those explains it, QNAP says to collect system dump logs and contact QNAP Support.
During the rebuild
QNAP's disk-warning FAQ lists what to watch: the pool turning read-only during the rebuild; a rebuild that keeps stopping, which may mean another disk is faulty, so back up immediately; and a failure in the same slot after the rebuild, in which case test the disk on a PC with a diagnostic tool.
When to stop and get help
Stop and back up if another member disk shows a S.M.A.R.T. warning or bad blocks before or during the rebuild, if the rebuild keeps stopping, or if the pool goes read-only. A rebuild reads every remaining disk in full; QNAP's advice when a second disk looks faulty is to back up immediately rather than push on.
Questions
Why didn't my QNAP start rebuilding after I replaced the drive?
QNAP says inserting a replacement drive into a degraded RAID group usually starts a rebuild automatically. If it does not, assign the drive with Manage > Configure Spare Disk on the degraded RAID group, and rebuilding starts immediately.
How big does the replacement drive need to be?
QNAP says it must be equal to or larger than each current RAID member drive.
Does this work if the RAID group is inactive?
No. QNAP's FAQ only applies to RAID in degraded mode, with the number of failed drives within fault tolerance. For an inactive or offline RAID group, QNAP points to its inactive RAID recovery procedure.
Sources
Every fact on this page comes from the vendor documents below, opened on 2026-11-13.
- QNAP FAQ: What to do if Rebuilding does not Start when a New Drive is Plugged in degraded mode? (last modified 2026-08-11)
- QNAP QTS 5.1.x documentation: Configuring a RAID group hot spare
- QNAP QTS 5.1.x documentation: Recovering a RAID group with a Degraded status
- QNAP QTS 5.1.x documentation: Storage pool status
- QNAP QTS 5.1.x documentation: Disk statuses
- QNAP FAQ: What should I do if I see a disk error or storage related warning message?