NAS Codex › QNAP › QNAP "Disk X: Medium error" in the system log: what it means and what to do

QNAP "Disk X: Medium error" in the system log: what it means and what to do

You opened the QNAP system log and found [Hardware Status] Disk X: Medium error., or a notification that adds "Run a bad block scan on the drive." This page sets out what QNAP's own FAQ says the message means, the checks QNAP gives, and the point at which QNAP says the disk should be replaced.

Written against: QTS and QuTS hero (QNAP FAQ last modified 2022-12-06; QTS 5.1.x documentation). Last Updated: November 2026. Vendor menus and wording change between versions; if yours differ, follow the vendor page linked under Sources.

Before anything else: if the data on this NAS is not backed up somewhere else, copy it off first. Do not continue with any step on this page until you have.

Fast Answer

QNAP describes the message as informational: "As long as your storage pools are functional, your data will not be damaged or lost." It means the NAS could not read some data from that disk. Open Storage & Snapshots > Storage > Disks/VJBOD, select the disk, open its health information and run a S.M.A.R.T. test. If the disk health turns to Warning, plan to replace it soon. If it turns to Error, QNAP says it must be replaced immediately.

The two forms of the message

QNAP documents the message in two places. The medium-error FAQ shows the System Event Log line:

[Hardware Status] Disk X: Medium error.

QNAP's general disk-warning FAQ lists a longer version among the alerts that mean a disk should be replaced if they keep appearing:

Host: Disk X: Medium error. Run a bad block scan on the drive. Replace the drive if the error persists

"Disk X" is the drive bay number, so note it before you do anything else.

What QNAP says causes it

According to the FAQ, a medium error means the system cannot read data from a device. QNAP links this to checksum mismatches, usually from data corruption or bad blocks on the disk. The errors can be temporary or permanent. A common side effect is higher input/output latency while the NAS recovers the data, so the NAS may feel slow while it is happening.

The key point in QNAP's note is the condition attached to "your data will not be damaged or lost": the storage pools must still be functional. Check that first.

Step 1: Check the storage pool

Go to Storage & Snapshots > Storage > Storage/Snapshots and look at the pool that contains the disk. QNAP's storage pool status table defines the states you may see:

Pool statusQNAP's description
ReadyThe storage pool is working normally. All RAID groups in the pool have the status Ready.
Warning (Degraded)One or more RAID groups have the status Degraded, and there are not enough spare disks to rebuild them all.
Warning (Rebuilding)One or more RAID groups are being rebuilt due to disk failure.
Warning (Read-Only)One or more RAID groups in the pool have the status Not Active.

If the pool is anything other than Ready, stop here and read the degraded and read-only page first. A medium error on top of a degraded pool is a different situation.

Step 2: Read the disk's health

These are the steps from QNAP's medium-error FAQ:

  1. Go to Storage & Snapshots > Storage > Disks/VJBOD. (The FAQ prints it as "Disk/VJBOD"; QNAP's QTS 5.1 documentation and other FAQs use "Disks/VJBOD".)
  2. Select the disk in the bay named in the log.
  3. Click Disk Health (in the QTS 5.1 documentation the button is labelled Health).
  4. Check the disk health summary and the S.M.A.R.T. information. QNAP notes that an attribute's status changes to Warning when it reaches the manufacturer's or QTS's threshold.
  5. Go to Test and run a S.M.A.R.T. test.

QNAP's QTS 5.1 documentation describes two S.M.A.R.T. tests. The Rapid Test checks the disk's electrical and mechanical properties and a small part of the surface, and takes about one minute. The Complete Test checks the electrical and mechanical properties and the whole surface; how long it takes depends on the storage environment.

Step 3: Scan for bad blocks

The longer form of the message asks for a bad block scan. In QTS 5.1, QNAP's disk actions page puts it at Storage & Snapshots > Storage > Disks/VJBOD > Disks, select the disk, then Action > Scan for Bad Blocks, with the tip: "Run this scan if the disk's status changes to Warning or Error." The bad block result then appears in the disk's health summary.

Step 4: Decide by the health status

QNAP's QTS 5.1 disk status table defines the health values:

HealthQNAP's description
GoodThe disk is normal.
WarningThe system has detected S.M.A.R.T. errors. Run a full S.M.A.R.T. test and a disk scan.
ErrorThe system has detected I/O errors. You must replace the disk immediately.

The medium-error FAQ adds that moving disks between bays can sometimes work around the errors, but if they persist the disk may have bad blocks and need replacing. Do not shuffle disks around in a pool you have not backed up: a mistake there is worse than the medium error itself.

If you do need to replace the disk, QNAP's FAQ suggests clicking RAID Group to see which RAID group the disk belongs to and its RAID type, so you know whether the pool can survive the disk being removed. The replacement procedure is on the S.M.A.R.T. warning page.

When to stop and get help

Stop and back up, or contact QNAP support, if the pool shows Warning (Degraded), Warning (Read-Only) or Not Active, or if a second disk is also logging medium errors or S.M.A.R.T. warnings. Replacing a disk while another one is failing puts the whole RAID group at risk.

Questions

Is a QNAP medium error dangerous?

QNAP's FAQ calls it informational and says that as long as your storage pools are functional, your data will not be damaged or lost. It does mean the NAS could not read some data from that disk, so check the disk's health and run a S.M.A.R.T. test.

When should I replace a disk with medium errors?

QNAP says to replace the disk soon if its S.M.A.R.T. status is Warning, and immediately if its status has turned to Error. The longer log message also says to replace the drive if the error persists after a bad block scan.

Where is Disk Health in QTS?

Go to Storage & Snapshots > Storage > Disks/VJBOD, select the disk and click Disk Health (Health in QTS 5.1). The Test tab runs a S.M.A.R.T. test.

Sources

Every fact on this page comes from the vendor documents below, opened on 2026-11-13.